Nate, you're giving us obsessive, nitpicky, unpleasable fans a bad name.
Also, ALTERNATE TIMELINE, Earth 2, Ultimate Marvel, What-If world, out-of-canon romp. Just chill out and watch the damn thing first.
(I know it's weird that I of all people should be saying that, but I watched a whole three episodes of Enterprise before I decided it was crap).
I agree with Derek about the guy playing McCoy. I could almost hear De Kelly at times. I also liked all the little references and in-jokes (figures) they threw in.
Apart from those nitpicks, I was quite impressed with it. Scotty sounded more like Dr. Beckett, but that's OK.